Sugar Cookies

The Magical Baker is a home bakery specializing in gluten free goodies, made from scratch - no boxed mixes here! I'm able to sell baked goods due to a Cottage Foods License.

Please visit the Special Orders page if you'd like to place an order! If it's for a special event on a select date (such as birthdays, anniversaries, etc), I recommend you place your order at least 1 month ahead (or further ahead, if possible), as pickup dates may fill up quickly.

Sugar cookie pricing is based on complexity of designs involved, as that equates to more time spent decorating the cookies. Each price is for one batch, which makes one dozen cookies that are approximately 3-3.5" at their widest point. Larger cookies can be made by request, but there will be fewer cookies per batch price.

Sugar Cookie Pricing Tiers

Classic cookie flavors:

Vanilla Almond (nut free almond flavor also available upon request)

Vanilla

Lemon

Marshmallow

Specialty cookie flavors ($1 more per dozen):

Unless otherwise noted, Specialty flavors are made without any gluten, dairy, tree nuts, peanuts, soy, or sesame

Apple Spice

Banana

Banana Cinnamon

Banana Nut (contain nuts or nut free flavoring)

Banana Rum

Eggnog

Lemon Raspberry

Pumpkin Spice

Raspberry

Signature Cookie Flavors ($2 more per dozen):

Unless otherwise noted, Signature flavors are made without any gluten, dairy, tree nuts, peanuts, soy, or sesame

Chocolate

Chocolate Banana

Chocolate Gingerbread

Gingerbread

Maple (gf & df, or gf & nut free)

Mexican Hot Chocolate

Orange

Peanut Butter (contain peanuts)

Speculoos/Bischoff

Deluxe Cookie Flavors ($5 more per dozen):

Unless otherwise noted, Deluxe flavors are made without any gluten, dairy, tree nuts, peanuts, soy, or sesame

Orange Chocolate Chip

Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip (contain peanuts)

Strawberry Chocolate Chip

Any sugar cookie flavor can be made without eggs, upon request ($1 more per dozen)

Vegan/eggless royal icing also available ($1 more per dozen)

The Basic

$25 per dozen classic undecorated cookies

The DIY (aka Cookie Decorating Kit)

$35 per dozen undecorated cookies, with 1-3 colors of buttercream frosting or royal icing. Please note: royal icing can take many hours to dry - if you think you'll want to eat the cookies soon after decorating, I would recommend opting for buttercream instead.